CloudFlare Hostname

Hi, I'm new here - please forgive me. I have done a quick prelim search on here just to check my question hasn't already been answered, and I appreciate this is more of a cloudflare issue - however, wasn't sure if anyone had come across the same thing. So, here's how i'd like my DNS to work (not sure if it's possible) All managed via cloudflare. server1.domain.com (not cpanel) - already managed and working via cloudflare server2.domain.com - cannot access via cloudflare Tried adding server2 as an A record, pointing to server IP Any ideas? Ideally, I'd just like to keep all my server host names on the same domain using cloudflare. Sorry for the long winded post